Louise’s Blog

Web-Resource Criteria

I have recently discovered a grammar site which, upon a quick glance, looked like a good reference site to use in my class.  I chose this site – Quick and Dirty Tips – Education – to review according to the following criteria:

 

SITE
Web address? (edu / gov / org / com / k12)       It is a .com.
Name/Title?       The title Quick and Dirty Tips does not seem very professional, yet has a fun feel.  It is not solely based on education, but definitely has a comprehensive cover of key issues in grammar usage.
Easy to navigate?       Yes   
Working links?       Yes

WHO
Name of author/creator?       Mignon Fogarty
Biography / proof of expertise?       B.A. in English from University of Washington and M.S. in Biology from Stanford University, magazine writer, technical writer, author of 7 books, entrepreneur, senior editor and producer of number of health and science websites         
Way to connect with author?      Google+, Twitter, Facebook, StumbleUpon, LinkedIn, and Pinterest.  Provides opportunity for questions, report of technical problems, and media or speaking inquiries – links don’t work.  However, if you go to the bio page, the link to her email works.

DATE
When was site created?       Earliest record: 2006.  Copyright 2016.
When was the last update?       New posts are added with regular intervals.
Date of post?       Each new post is dated.

SPONSORS/ENDORSEMENT OF SITE
Reputable?       Writer’s Digest, Writer’s market, Writer’s Digest University & Writer’s Digest Shop.  Awards:  Best Writing Website, and 29 other awards (website and podcasts)
Related to theme of site?        Yes

INFO
True / useful?          Yes
Mechanics: spelling, grammar, punctuation?          Lenient approach to use of punctuation
Citations provided?          Yes
Generalized, biased statements vs. factual, proven, objective (depending on the site)?          Factual and correct

 

To summarize:  I like the feel of this website.  Clearly she has made a name for herself in the grammar and writing world.  I find her use of punctuation when explaining rules a little lenient, but there is no other issues.  It is a great source.

 



1 comment so far ↓

  • #   lkondos on 10.06.16 at 23:15     

    Using Delano’s criteria: http://www.quickanddirtytips.com/grammar-girl

    10 SECOND GLANCE

    URL: .com = commercial
    Author: Mignon Fogarty
    Purpose: Teach
    Links: Many links to podcasts, as well as to additional (reputable) websites

    60 SECOND SCAN

    Authority: Fair
    POV: A personal, first person approach
    Profession: managing director, author, podcaster, editor
    Reputable? Yes
    Pass the smell test? A fun website to use as reference for grammar issues. She touches on common errors made by students, and provides good explanations and examples to clarify.


You must log in to post a comment.